Explore the best 2025 4 Star Hotels Hotels in Key West Historic District

"Gorgeous property . The room is beautiful and breakfast was amazing as well as the gardens"

"Amazing property. The room was very clean, it was in a great location. The staff was friendly. Loved the amenities! It has a small workout room, with a decent selection of weights. The only complaint is we were located in the Tranquility building and it was noisy at night. I bought ear plugs after the first night and was able to get rest the rest of the trip, however my roommate did not use them and was woken up each night from people coming back to the hotel around 2-3 am. I would come back but stay closer to the beach next time. "

"The Reach was the nicest resort I’ve ever stayed at. The location of the resort is right on the water away from the hustle and bustle of Duvall but close enough to walk there. The private beach is gorgeous. The pool area is full of fun (young and old). Food and drinks from the restaurant flowing all day. The grounds are pristine. Then you get to the staff. From Smiley our housekeeper to Rickey, who was one of the nicest staff members I’ve ever met. They were all incredible. When we come back to Key West, we are staying at the Reach. "

"The property was very beautiful. The room was so nice. "

"Location is great. Food and service great also"

"I loved the location and the staff were so nice!"