Explore top 2026 4 Star Hotels in Point Loma

"My husband and I visit San Diego once or twice a year for a week or two at a time. We love staying on shelter island because of it’s charm and location. Humphrys has always been on our list so we decided to try it this time around. The positive side, the location at the start of shelter island is ideal. Also, the check-in was wonderful and very smooth. We got a junior suite overlooking the bay and the size was great. The property is also beautiful and the heated pool was a plus! The bad… our room was dirty. Sheets were clean and we had fresh towels but the floor in the bathroom was gross. The floor around the toilet had a questionable stained area that was outlined in red. We thought maybe it just was missed but it did not get cleaned for our entire stay. We laid towels on the floor to walk on. Our tub was also clogged. So much so that my 15 minute showers would fill the tub. Our mattress was worn out. Both sides had wells. My husband was so stiff by the end of the week, we drug the mattress into the living room and laid it on the floor for the last night. Normally these kind of things don’t both us. It’s an old hotel, we get it. However, we told the hotel staff about the tub three different times during our 5 night stay. It was never fixed. For the mattress, I asked if there was anything at all that could be done and was told that the mattress couldn’t possibly be worn out because it had just been switched out. I was dismissed. I think there are better options for SI."

"Property renovations are completed. Looks good."

"The breakfast had a good variety."

"Roaches"

"Clean room and great staff, front desk Kimberly was a big help. She greeted me well and let me know about attractions in the area. Kind hearted and really genuine person, I wish more places I stayed at had more people like her. Probably deserves a raise 😁"

"We love the hotel for the free parking and steps to the beach. It just is a little too expensive . We would go there more if the prices were lower. "