Book Hotels in Old Tappan, NJ
Cabins, apartments, houseboats! We offer comfortable & private vacation rentals
Save an extra 10% or more on select hotels with Member Discounts
Access exclusive hotel deals, only with the Travelocity app
Check prices for these dates
Top Old Tappan hotels

Hyatt Regency Times Square
"need a small microwave in the room but everything else was AMAZING!"
Reviewed on Jun 9, 2026

Pod Times Square
"Pods is very good, room cleaned, great location and staff very nice."
Reviewed on Jun 9, 2026

Hotel Edison Times Square
"Gio at the front door / valet area was awesome and super helpful!! He deserves a raise!"
Reviewed on Jun 9, 2026

Hyatt Grand Central New York
"Sheet cover had small stain and a strand of hair found in the sheets. Quickly sorted but no a good start. Apart from that no issues. Good central location. Homeless and others are around but no problem. Just leads to the atmosphere. Not under the control of the hotel."
Reviewed on Jun 9, 2026

NEW YORKER BY LOTTE HOTELS
"Check in staff the day I came were friendly. Location was prime. Would visit again"
Reviewed on Jun 9, 2026

Row NYC
"The staff were amazing—friendly, welcoming, and always willing to help. The complimentary happy hour from 5–6 PM was a wonderful touch, and I especially appreciated that they offered mocktails for guests who don’t drink. I also had the best night's sleep I've had in years. The blackout shades worked ..."
Reviewed on Jun 9, 2026

Empire Hotel
"Loved the hotel. Very beautiful"
Reviewed on Jun 9, 2026

Paramount Times Square – A Generator Hotel
"Not a great hotel"
Reviewed on Jun 9, 2026

Sheraton New York Times Square Hotel
"Staff was very friendly and accommodating. The location is absolutely top notch. My only complaints are about the gym. Some of the equipment is in disrepair."
Reviewed on Jun 9, 2026
Hotels in Old Tappan with star-rating
Check Old Tappan Hotels by Star Rating

2 Star Hotels
Old Tappan Hotel & Travel Guide\n
With 19 hotels and apartments in Old Tappan, travelers here are able to be discerning. Within a convenient driving distance of where the locals can be found in Old Tappan, you'll find 19 places to rest and relax.
Travelocity-listed hotel options that aren't far from the commercial district of Old Tappan include the Hilton Pearl River and Holiday Inn Orangeburg-Rockland/Bergen Co.
The The St. Regis New York can be found 17 miles (28 kilometers) outside of downtown Old Tappan. An alternative accommodation option is the Mandarin Oriental, New York, which is positioned 17 miles (27 kilometers) away. Two more alternatives around Old Tappan include the Trump International Hotel & Tower New York and the The Plaza Hotel.
How about you get close to some more of the coastal plains and forests that are commonly found in North Jersey? Opt to take time in some of the other fascinating areas of North Jersey. Enlightened visitors can travel among this region's diverse places of interest or enjoy snowboarding, skiing and cross-country skiing and afterwards reserve a suitable hotel to stay the night.
Want more to do? Consider spending a few hours seeing Kean University and Turtle Back Zoo, which you'll find in Newark, 20 miles (35 kilometers) southwest of Old Tappan. The Newark Liberty International Airport Marriott and Hilton Newark Penn Station are a few of the Travelocity-listed long and short-stay alternatives in Newark. 30 miles (50 kilometers) west of Old Tappan, you may also choose to stay at Mcafee, home to the Grand Cascades Lodge and Minerals Hotel. The Bear Peak Express and South Peak Express are a couple of the more popular attractions to experience should you visit Mcafee.
If cheering on sport if on your list of things to do, make the time to visit Madison Square Garden, which is 18 miles (29 kilometers) to the south of Old Tappan. If you like the idea of checking in to a room close to the stadium, book in the The Lowell or Four Seasons Hotel New York.
Westchester County Airport is the most logical airport for flights out of Old Tappan. It's situated 15 miles (24 kilometers) away. Doral Arrowwood is nearby.
Frequently asked questions
Recent Old Tappan hotel reviews by fellow wanderers

Row NYC
"The staff were amazing—friendly, welcoming, and always willing to help. The complimentary happy hour from 5–6 PM was a wonderful touch, and I especially appreciated that they offered mocktails for guests who don’t drink. I also had the best night's sleep I've had in years. The blackout shades worked so well that we woke up at 10 AM convinced it was still the middle of the night! Being so well-rested made a huge difference for our busy days exploring the city. The location was another major plus, especially for my Broadway-loving family. Overall, an exceptional stay. One million stars!"
Explore More Ways to Travel with Travelocity
- Extended Stay Hotels in Woodcliff Lake
- Woodcliff Lake Hotels
- Condos in Montvale
- Extended Stay Hotels in Montvale
- Adventure Hotels in Montvale
- Romantic Getaways & Hotels in Montvale
- Spa Resorts & in Montvale
- Hotel Wedding Venues Hotels in Montvale
- Montvale Hotels
- Motels in Montvale
- Vacation Homes in Montvale
- Oradell Hotels
- Hotels near Bergen County Players
- Hotels near Paramus Park Mall
- 3 Star Hotels in Emerson
- Apartments in Emerson
- B&B in Emerson
- Condos in Emerson
- Cottages in Emerson
- Luxury Hotels in Emerson
- Emerson Hotels
- Hotels near White Beeches Country Club
- Hotels near Haworth Country Club
- Saddle River Hotels
- Hotels near Bookends
- Upper Saddle River Hotels
- Dumont Hotels
- Motels in Closter
- Motels in Hillsdale
- Cresskill Hotels
- Bergenfield Hotels
- Hotels near Ciccone Theatre
- 5 Star Hotels in Northvale
- Apartments in Northvale
- Condos in Northvale
- Cottages in Northvale
- Extended Stay Hotels in Northvale
- Guest Houses in Northvale
- Hotels near Tice's Corner
- Hotels near Demarest Nature Center
- Apartments in Park Ridge
- B&B in Park Ridge
- Cottages in Park Ridge
- Extended Stay Hotels in Park Ridge
- Hostels in Park Ridge
- Gay Friendly Hotels in Park Ridge
- Hotels with Pools in Park Ridge
- Hotels with Balconies in Park Ridge
- Hotels with Hot Tubs in Park Ridge
- Spa Resorts & in Park Ridge
- Park Ridge Hotels
- Rv Parks in Park Ridge
- Villas in Park Ridge
- Apartments in Westwood
- B&B in Westwood
- Cottages in Westwood
- Extended Stay Hotels in Westwood
- Guest Houses in Westwood
- Hostels in Westwood
- Kid Friendly Hotels in Westwood
- Hotels with Pools in Westwood
- Pet Friendly Hotels in Westwood
- Spa Resorts & in Westwood
- Westwood Hotels
- Motels in Westwood
- Vacation Homes in Westwood
- Paramus Hotels
- Hotels near Palisades Interstate Park
- River Edge Hotels
- Hotels near Ridgewood Country Club
- Ho Ho Kus Hotels
- Hotels near Bergen Regional Medical Center
- Waldwick Hotels
- Hotels near Van Saun County Park
- 5 Star Hotels in Norwood
- Apartments in Norwood
- Cottages in Norwood
- Hostels in Norwood
- Norwood Hotels
- Inns in Norwood
- Villas in Norwood
- Rockleigh Hotels
- Inns in Rockleigh
- Farmstay in Demarest
- Motels in Demarest
- Vacation Homes in Demarest
- Cabins in River Vale
- Motels in River Vale
- Tenafly Hotels






