Explore top 2026 4 Star Hotels in Islamorada

"Pool heater on back order. Above ground pool. Otherwise great place."

"Great place. Relaxing"

"We had a fantastic stay at Three Waters Resort and Marina. The ocean view room with terrace (Atlantic Shores) was beautiful, and being just steps from the beach and pools made it incredibly easy to relax and enjoy every moment. The included amenities: paddle boards, kayaks, bikes, etc. made it easy to stay active without any extra planning. The staff was genuinely friendly and welcoming, and with several on-site dining options, we never felt the need to leave the resort to find something to do or somewhere great to eat. It truly had everything we needed for a fun, stress-free getaway."

"The hotel is trying to be something it’s not. It’s tired, needs kept up and that’s just not happening. The toilet in the lobby bathroom was broke for two days, hand pump shampoo in the shower broke, towel hook hanging in a thread, wallpaper peeling in the bathroom, door splitting/splintering off at the bottom, basket seats cushions in the lobby splitting, hallway walls dirty. If I mentioned anything broken it was ignored. They just closed the lid on the toilet and ignored the mountain of TP in it. Rooms need better lamps, they were so dim lit you couldn’t see at night. The restaurant and food situation was confusing and nonexistent with no signage. The landscaping out front and courtyard area in the back were beautiful, fire-pit and tiki areas were really nice. Pool closes at sundown and no hot-tub. If you book a balcony room, disclaimer: you may get an ugly roof view like we did. To move to a different room is $70 extra per night to a room you feel like you completely overpaid for already. The sister property Three Waters is much better quality, cheaper, and had more amenities. Most of the staff were not friendly and seemed like they didn’t want to be there or help (except for the front desk staff, they were phenomenal). When my 15 y/o son notices things are off (and wants to leave immediately (and normally cares about nothing) that’s a sure sign it’s really bad. He wants to stay at a Marriott next time so we are not snookered into a terrible stay at a terrible price."

"Great property but the bar area was not opened during our stay. The staff was great and the beach and pool were great to relax to"

"Room looked clean upon arrival but soon realized floors were filthy- you couldn’t walk barefoot without getting your feet all black. They also did not ever clean our room or provide with fresh towels/any other basic house keeping during my stay. "