Explore top 2026 4 Star Hotels in Sugarloaf Shores

"Nice pool, great breakfast, loves the bikes and kayaks and shuttle to Duval."

"Very clean room, but tiny showers. The front desk staff were not very welcoming but everyone else was. "

"I would rate the property of three star. It could be better. The one thing I didn’t notice on my first Barr bill when I walked in as they automatically give you on the bill at 18% tip, but you don’t realize drinks are pretty expensive all over Key West but when you have $100 bill you don’t know there’s 18% included than you tip on top of that I think they should say something but they don’t so that was a problem for me. The rooms are clean but they could use a makeover and I also was told by $50 per night charge was included when it wasn’t so when I checked out, I had an extra $200 bill for Hotel fees, but we don’t know what Hotel fees are"

"Pool atmosphere and Mojitos Bar were pleasant. Employees were kind to assist throughout the resort! Shuttle dude, Mario, very friendly and well -versed about the Keys! "

"Beautiful hotel we had a great time the staff is always concerned with making your stay the best thank you Flora and staff "

"No room view but enjoyed the pool. "