Explore top 2026 4 Star Hotels in Rye

"Mixed feelings about this hotel- the staff is amazing, rooms are large for NYC and nice and well appointed. Great quality shampoo/lotion etc in rooms. The hotel is large and has lots of great amenities- on property spa, fitness center plus free access to Lifetime fitness across the street , dry-bar, nice bar /lounge area to work or drink and relax with table service , room service 24/7, on site restaurants. And the location is great. What is not good: the building is old (clearly renovated but the HVAC and windows show their age- the HVAC spit some sort of soot or mold onto my suitcase and clothes- and into the air I was breathing. The fitness center in the hotel has no windows and apparently poor ventilation (smelled of sweat when I walked in- could remedy this by walking across street to lifetime); the smell of burgers cooking on a grill (from the burger joint restaurant on site and below) was so overwhelming in my room (opening window made it worse- apparently the restaurant may be venting to the space my window faced)- but they moved me to 20th floor and that helped. In short- not sure I would stay here again. But it is a really nice hotel other than the noted issues. The Thompson in Nashville is fabulous and this one is not nearly as good (to be fair the Nashville one is in a new building). "

"Rooms was clean"

"2nd fl,hall smelled like weed carpet was dirty,elevator carpert dirty outside dirty"

"The room was really great! Unfortunately, we booked this hotel for the pool and it was closed for maintenance which was really disappointing. I would stay here again, as long as I called ahead to make sure the pool would be open."

"It is definitely an older hotel; overall, great option hotel for Lincoln Square. Lots of food options and shops around. The hotel is foodless, no snacks, drinks, nor breakfast. My only upset is that the entire hotel lacks microwaves. I had most of my amazing lasagna from Cafe Friellos stored in the fridge but no way of heating it up. Bummer."

"The staff were great and we were highly satisfied with the excellent location of our hotel. However, our room was not cleaned/tidied the second night of our stay. We watched the cleaning staff enter the room that same morning so unsure what happened."