Explore top 2026 5 Star Hotels in Castleton

"The fitness center was well equipped, the bar area is very nice, and the location was great. It would have been nice to have an on site laundry & although this is a historic beautiful hotel, it is also very expensive. I always find it ironic that the more expensive a hotel is, the fewer amenities are included with your stay. No free parking, breakfast or even coffee in the lobby."

"We appreciate the amenities and having an outdoor bench. There are nice areas to sit and visit with family🙂"

"We were very impressed with our stay!! The rooms were updated, spacious, and very clean! The breakfast had many things to choose from and very delicious. The hors d’oeuvres were amazing and many things to choose from!! They had all the drink choices you would want and very comfortable dining area! The fitness room and pool areas were very clean and equipment and pools very nice! You could tell it was all kept up. We had a fabulous stay and will definitely stay again!! We appreciate it all and very friendly staff!! "

"Great experience "

"Best Indy Hotel!! It is fabulous in every aspect. The manager, Terri, is incredible! "

"Check-in was quick and easy. The room was nice and clean. We went to the bar for a couple of drinks later that evening, the bartender was super nice. We had a delicious breakfast the next morning, and a quick and easy checkout. We look forward to booking another stay in the future!"