Book a hotel near Grumman Memorial Park, Calverton

"Quiet and great options for food and relaxation"

"Good job you didn’t good I be so proud "

"Very pleasant experience "

"Good stay"

"We don’t usually stay at motels. But these rooms were very, very nice and well designed. They were cute! The motel staff were friendly and accommodating."

"There’s an old film from the 1960s, Brigadoon, where a magical village appears for just one day before vanishing again. Staying at The Lindsey feels a bit like that—so perfect, so improbable, you wonder if it exists once you leave.The backyard is the heart of this home. Mornings began with coffee in an Adirondack chair overlooking a private park-like lawn. The crystal-clear saltwater pool is surrounded by loungers, umbrellas, and even two submerged chairs for reading while you cool off. From morning to evening, the patio offered something for everyone—lunches by the Weber grill, s’mores around the fire pit, and hot tub soaks under the stars.Inside, the house is spacious, comfortable, and thoughtfully designed. The primary suite features a large spa-like shower, while additional bedrooms easily accommodated our family. The kitchen is fully stocked and opens to a casual family room with a big sectional and smart TV. We also enjoyed the elegant dining room, the sunny breakfast nook (which became our Lego HQ), and the garage with a second fridge, pool table, and dartboard.The biggest surprise was Wading River itself. Sunflower fields, farm stands, and a calm, timeless atmosphere made it feel worlds away from the bustle of the Cape or Berkshires—even in peak season. The Lindsey isn’t just a vacation rental—it’s a place where mornings spill into long afternoons, and nights stretch happily into memory. That’s if it exists at all — until next year!"