Find a Hotel in Bay Island

Seize Your Someday with our amazing deals for the whole family!

Save an extra 10% or more on select hotels with Member Discounts

Access exclusive hotel deals, only with the Travelocity app

Bay Island Hotel Guide

Don’t keep your travel plans on repeat year after year. The same city with the same hotel every season will bore you and give you an itch to go looking for something new. Expand your geographical horizons to more than just those five blocks around your usual haunt.

Nowhere else can you find better deals on Bay Island area hotels. You’ll find the best prices on the quirky, the haunted, the old, the new, and the legendary. If you’re wondering what side of the pricing scale some of these hotels fall on, you need not to worry. Compare cheap hotels near Bay Island to find the perfect one to will fit your budget.

Leave the ordinary routine you’re set on behind and go. Go anywhere you want. Anywhere that makes you think, “I wonder what that’s like?” Part of Travelocity’s mission is to get you off-the-beaten path and the hotels near Bay Island are perfect for that. Find your new favorite watering hole on a quiet street. Discover a place to escape for the weekend with tasty local fare and unique sights. We want you to consider the places outside your normal comfort zone. Browse our selection and find the ideal hotel, in a place you’d like to explore.

Recent Bay Island hotel reviews by fellow wanderers

Carlisle Inn

5 out of 5

Posted 1 hour ago

Travelocity Verified Review

"We LOVED staying at Carlisle and I hope we are able to stay again soon! We paid a bit extra for the executive king suite and it was really nice to have the extra room since we were spending a good amount of time in the hotel before a minor surgery I had the next day. The room was IMPECCABLE! The bed and the room were both so comfortable. I slept great before my surgery. Hubby and I loved the cookies, and he also enjoyed the Boston cream donuts which was part of the breakfast spread. He did want me to mention that there was a noise. To me it sounded a little like cars driving outside the room (not very loud in my opinion)- but it was like a generator or something. It didn’t bother me and I felt like our sound machine helped block it out, but he said it kept him awake a little in the night. I think it may have had to do with the placement of where our room (201) was located in the hotel. The pillows were really soft/squishy, I do wish they were a bit more firm, but this was minor. I highly recommend this hotel would return back here."

A verified traveler stayed at Carlisle Inn

Spark by Hilton Sarasota Siesta Key Gateway

4 out of 5

Posted 2 days ago

Travelocity Verified Review

"If I had known hot tub was not working, I would have not booked or stayed there. Chose this property because after a very long driving day, i just needed that soak! Speaking of soaking.... there are ZERO directions how to turn water on your goofy showers...so no water for me this stay, at all!"

A verified traveler stayed at Spark by Hilton Sarasota Siesta Key Gateway