Beginning of main content

Book Hotels in Shelter Island, New York from

Wander Wisely with the Travelocity Price Match Guarantee

Trip Type
Flight 1
Flight 2
Flight 3
Flight 4
Flight 5

Get 24/7 travel help, thanks to our Customer First Guarantee

Save an extra 10% or more on select hotels with Member Discounts

Access exclusive hotel deals, only with the Travelocity app

Most Frequently Booked Shelter Island Hotels

Shelter Island Retreat Get Rates
See details
 
Shelter Island Retreat

Shelter Island Retreat

Shelter Island, New York
     
    0.0 out of 5.0 Stars

    A spa tub is featured at this vacation home, along with a garden.

    Shelter Island Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach Get Rates
    See details
     
    Shelter Island Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach

    Shelter Island Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach

    Shelter Island, New York
       
      0.0 out of 5.0 Stars

      A garden is available at this vacation home.

      New Listing: Technicolor Paradise, Architectural Masterpiece Amidst Woodlands & Beaches, Heated Pool Get Rates
      See details
       
      New Listing: Technicolor Paradise, Architectural Masterpiece Amidst Woodlands & Beaches, Heated Pool

      New Listing: Technicolor Paradise, Architectural Masterpiece Amidst Woodlands & Beaches, Heated Pool

      Shelter Island, New York
         
        0.0 out of 5.0 Stars

        A spa tub is featured at this vacation home, along with a garden.

        Shelter Island Cottage With Pool, Walk to Beaches and Mashomack Preserve Get Rates
        See details
         
        Shelter Island Cottage With Pool, Walk to Beaches and Mashomack Preserve

        Shelter Island Cottage With Pool, Walk to Beaches and Mashomack Preserve

        Shelter Island, New York
           
          0.0 out of 5.0 Stars

          Situated in Shelter Island, this vacation home is within 1 mi (2 km) of Wades Beach, Havens House, and Shelter Island Historical Society. Mashomack Preserve and Shelter Island Whale's Tail are also within 2 mi (3 km).

          Map

          How Much is a Hotel Room in Shelter Island?

          Hotels in Shelter Island start at per night. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

          Cheap Hotels in Shelter Island

          Pack your bags—it’s time to embark on a getaway. Whether you’re craving a solo retreat or promising your family a vacation to remember, book one of the best hotels in Shelter Island. These hotels are located within easy access of the city’s hottest attractions and entertainment, so you won’t miss a beat while you’re in town. Spend the days exploring the local landmarks and the evenings getting to know the nightlife. After exploring the city from top to bottom, rest up at a hotel that speaks to you. Find the perfect place that matches your trip’s vibe, from a trendy boutique to family-friendly accommodations.

          Allow us here at Travelocity to pair you with up Shelter Island hotels that suit your vacation preferences. Discover places with convenient on-site restaurants, around-the-clock service, and pools where your kids can make a splash. Some hotels may boast fitness rooms and spa services, while others feature game rooms and Wi-Fi access. To top it all off, you’ll score cheap hotels in Shelter Island that let you spend more on your activities and less on your lodging. Book and bundle your flight and hotel deals together today and save up to $537. It’s time to explore a new city, and break out of your routine.

          Recent Shelter Island Hotel Reviews By Fellow Wanderers

          Ocean Resort Inn

          5.0 Travelocity Verified Review
          It was clean, sanitary, friendly, and convenient ayeeee
          2 weeks ago by A verified traveler
          Open Ocean Resort Inn hotel guest reviews

          Haven Montauk

          5.0 Travelocity Verified Review
          The room was updated and very clean. I would definitely recommend this property!
          3 weeks ago by A verified traveler
          Open Haven Montauk hotel guest reviews

          Capri

          5.0 Travelocity Verified Review
          Had a great stay enjoy the facility The staff was great
          3 weeks ago by A verified traveler
          Open Capri hotel guest reviews

          Southampton Inn

          4.0 Travelocity Verified Review
          Close to the beach and the complementary bus to the beach. Waking distance to Main Street and restaurants. Nice room.
          3 weeks ago by A verified traveler
          Open Southampton Inn hotel guest reviews

          Pier Blue Guesthouse

          3.0 Travelocity Verified Review
          It needs updating! Bed was very comfortable, shower was good, towels were large and soft. The TV and internet did not work well. The price was very high for the condition of the property.
          1 month ago by A verified traveler
          Open Pier Blue Guesthouse hotel guest reviews

          Bowen's by the Bays

          5.0 Travelocity Verified Review
          Very unusual large garden with flowers tables and chairs CREATING A RELAXED ATMOSPHERE. ALSO THEY GIVE YOU A BAG WITH GOODIES AS YOU CHECK IN. FEELS LIKE A HOME! LOTS OF FLOWERS GRASS AND OPEN SPACES ROOMS AWAY FROM NOISE OF HIGHWAY. WOULD RECOMMEND IT TO ANYONE. PRICE VERY REASONABLE
          1 month ago by A verified traveler from NEW YORK
          Open Bowen's by the Bays hotel guest reviews

          An Airport

          An Attraction

          *Price based on the lowest price found within past 24 hours and based upon one night stay for two adults over the next thirty days. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.