Book Hotels in Shelter Island, NY

"From the front desk receptionist to checking out, everything was perfect. "

"Hospitality at its finest! Bed here was beyond comfortable❤️"

"A Truly Transcendent Weekend Escape: Impeccable Service and Luxury From the moment we arrived until the last minute of our departure, our anniversary weekend stay at Gurney’s was nothing short of perfection. This review is less about a hotel and more about an experience—one defined by luxury, comfort, and some of the most outstanding hospitality we’ve ever encountered. Our room was impeccable. It felt less like a hotel room and more like a private, beautifully curated sanctuary with an absolutely stunning view. It was the perfect space for relaxation after a busy week. The food at GiGi’s was a gastronomic delight. We enjoyed an exquisite breakfast there with a gorgeous view. The ingredients were fresh, the preparation was masterful, and the presentation elevated our dining experience. What truly sets this place apart, however, is the staff. Every single member of the team, without exception, provided service that was genuine, proactive, and friendly. From the seamless check-in, the entire valet team, the staff working the store, and most especially, the wait staff, their dedication to outstanding service made us feel uniquely valued. This level of consistent, outstanding care is rare, and it transformed our stay into a truly ten-star experience. I highly recommend Gurney’s to anyone seeking luxury, comfort, and service that goes above and beyond. We are already looking forward to our next visit."

"Staff was nice beautiful news"

"We love the Sound View. We stay every year for a girls’ weekend. Rooms are great with a beautiful view. One thing the rooms could use are a standing closet for your clothes. Otherwise, it’s lovely."

"An all round lovely experience. Perfect location and attention to detail. Lovely layout and amenities. It was a peaceful stay. "