Book a hotel near Mashomack Preserve, Shelter Island

"We enjoyed a pleasant 3 day stay at this lovely seaside inn. Comfortable and spacious room, a very friendly staff on all levels, and a convenient location on the North Fork if Long Island. Especially liked lunch at “Ellen’s” and Aldo is a great coffee shop. Would definitely visit and stay here again."

"Clean room and easy parking"

"This is a lovely motel located right on the Sound and all rooms face the water. The room was clean and relatively spacious, though most of the space was devoted to the kitchen and living areas. The bathroom was a bit small, as was the sleeping area. My family, including an elderly relative, traveled here for a family wedding in mid-April. The wedding was initially set to begin at 3:30 PM; check-in time is 4:00 PM. When I tried to arrange an earlier check-in time in advance, I was told that I would just have to take my chances because the motel was unwilling to guarantee an early check-in unless I also stayed the night before the wedding or paid a high hourly fee (i.e., roughly 1/3 of the room rate per hour of early check-in). Given that a significant percentage of the overnight guests were there for the wedding, and that one of the four rooms I reserved was for an elderly relative of the couple, I was taken aback by the motel management's rigidity. Fortunately, the couple was able to push back the time of the ceremony to accommodate their guests because the motel would not do so."

"This place is a perfect oasis in an already special environment. The host was wonderful and thoughtful. The cottage was magical and had everything to offer that one could want. "

"One staff member was there to check us in. He was helpful in bringing our bags to our room. He also suggested several restaurants for us to try."

"Super cute clean and well kept guest house. It was a bit of a hike to the pool. Our neighbors were a little noisy at one point, but not for long. The property manager was quick to respond and we had everything we needed!0"