Book a Cabin in Shelter Island, NY

Escape the concrete jungle at one of our charming cabins near Shelter Island. From to a night, they’re the perfect blend of creature comforts and nature. Prices reflect current offers and availability is subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Find a cabin around Shelter Island that suits your style from as little as a night. This was the cheapest rate offered in the last seven days. Prices reflect current offers and availability is subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Choose from one of 36 options here. If you’re in need of a cozy retreat away from the daily grind, a Shelter Island cabin rental is bound to please. Rustic Lakeside Cabin At White Gate Farm and Treehouse - Countryside - Farm Animals are two awesome choices.

Reserve one of our cheap cabin rentals and you’ll have boundless adventure to look forward to. Tailor-made for family groups, Shelter Island cabins are a popular base for exploring the very best of this area.

• First stop? Narragansett Beach. Around 85 mi to the northeast of Shelter Island, this family-friendly spot should be on your travel itinerary.
• Misquamicut State Beach, about 55 mi to the northeast of Shelter Island, is another appealing excursion. Pull out your camera and capture a beautiful family photo together.
• If you’re chasing someplace that’ll excite the whole gang, East Hampton Main Beach will make a great addition to your itinerary. This renowned family-friendly spot is about 19 mi to the southeast of Shelter Island.

When you’re ready to escape the city and tune into nature, a Shelter Island mountain cabin is a fantastic choice. Go on a hike, breathe in the fresh, clean air and then unwind at one of these escapes:

• Toss your bags down at Rustic Lakeside Cabin At White Gate Farm. A favorite with many tourists, this cozy cabin has everything you need for a lovely mountain vacation, including a microwave oven and a kitchen.
• After an action-packed day in nature, you’ll love coming home to Mohegan Cabin Estate. On top of the awesome views, it comes with winery tours and a microwave oven.

You don’t need to leave your furry friend at a pet hotel. Bring the dog along and stay in one of the pet-friendly cabins in Shelter Island. Here are two cabin retreats where Max can take part in the fun:

• Rustic Lakeside Cabin At White Gate Farm knows your pooch is part of your family. Book a few days here and make use of amenities including children’s activities and on-site watersports.
• Does your dog like being outdoors as much as you do? Then look up Remote Long Island Lakefront Cabin W, which has a deck and a queen bed in addition to gorgeous scenery.

Pack your board shorts and inflatable lounger. A Shelter Island cabin with a pool is the ideal escape, mixing comfort, nature and a splashing good time! Take the plunge at one of the following options:

• Arrange a stay at Cabin - Water Mill Wooded Escape. You’ll find lots of amenities here including a swimming pool and fitness facilities.
• Another wonderful stay is Spacious And New Deluxe Cabin In Family Campground In Northeastern Ct. As well as an inviting pool, you can take full advantage of on-site watersports and a swimming pool.

If spending your vacation looking for pretty ocean treasures on the shore and soaking up lovely sunrises over the water sounds magical to you, check out our Shelter Island beach cabin rentals. From small and homey to large and luxurious, we’ve got the ideal beachside stay for you:

• Toss your bags down and get comfy at Rustic Lakeside Cabin At White Gate Farm. As well as a host of other convenient amenities, it provides on-site watersports and beach sun loungers.
• Lagoon Lodge: North Fork, Charming 3br is another highly rated beachside cabin. Its amenities include clothes washing facilities and children’s activities.

Use Travelocity’s handy filter tool to track down a Shelter Island cabin that suits your style. First enter your travel dates. Then narrow your search using the checkboxes on the left of your browser. Hoping to stay flexible? Choose properties with free cancellation for extra peace of mind. If you find an even better price for the same cabin rental somewhere else within 24 hours of booking, we’ll refund you the difference. That’s our Price Guarantee.