Stayed 2 nights last week while in town for a wedding with 3 couples and 2 kids.
Pros: Very spacious, big private backyard to throw a football around. Nice touch to get to park in the garage. Kitchen was well stocked. Beds and bedrooms for couples were good sized and comfortable. Easy check in and check out. Good central location to restaurants, Costco, etc. Clean on arrival (minus dusty ceiling fans).
Cons: Most of the pillows were flat as pancakes. Linens need an upgrade. Our bedsheets were thin will holes. Towels were thin, and only had 7 bath towels for 8 people.
For the 2 kids sleeping in the living room, our teenage son couldn't fit on either the sofa or futon--he's 6 ft. He ended up sleeping uncomfortably on the floor on couch cushions that slid around. Listing said "sofa bed" so I assumed it was a pullout sleeper sofa but was wrong. Air mattress in closet didn't have a pump.
The space in this rental is so awesome, private, and quiet. If the owners could just do a refresh on the bedding (ESP pillows), and upgrade the living room couch situation, it'd easily be a 5-star accommodation.