Find and compare 3 Star hotels in Shelter Island
Seize Your Someday with our amazing deals for the whole family!
Save an extra 10% or more on select hotels with Member Discounts
Access exclusive hotel deals, only with the Travelocity app
Check prices for these dates
Top Shelter Island 3 Star hotels
Saybrook Point Resort & Marina
2 Bridge St Old Saybrook CT
Fully refundableReserve now, pay when you stay
$391 nightly
The price is $450 total per night from Aug 5 to Aug 6
$450 total
Aug 5 - Aug 6
Total with taxes and fees
A full-service spa, a marina, and 2 outdoor pools are all featured at this smoke-free hotel. Traveling on business? Take advantage of the free WiFi in public ...
9.6/10 Exceptional! (1,008 reviews)
"Very clean and updated room. Mattress and pillows were very comfortable. Nice furnishings and a large TV. The outdoor pool is not that big so you must get there before 8am to get a lounge. It was great to have a spa on site. My massage therapist was excellent. The check in was painless and the staff ..."
Reviewed on Jul 6, 2026
Zey Hotel
439 Main Street Greenport NY
$270 nightly
The price is $308 total per night from Jul 20 to Jul 21
$308 total
Jul 20 - Jul 21
Total with taxes and fees
A bar/lounge and a coffee shop are featured at this hotel, along with free self parking. WiFi in public areas is free. A terrace, a garden, and a picnic area ...
9.2/10 Wonderful! (347 reviews)
"We absolutely adored the Zey hotel. What a gem in the very heart of Greenport! Super clean and comfortable. All the staff were welcoming and accommodating. Eclectic design was so refreshing and fun. We highly recommend Zey hotel and look forward to staying there in the future. Thank you for making ..."
Reviewed on Jul 8, 2026
Water's Edge Resort & Spa
1525 Boston Post Road Westbrook CT
Fully refundableReserve now, pay when you stay
$314 nightly
The price is $361 total per night from Aug 12 to Aug 13
$361 total
Aug 12 - Aug 13
Total with taxes and fees
This smoke-free resort features a private beach, a full-service spa, and 3 restaurants. Relax with beach cabanas and sun loungers, and cool off with a drink ...
8.8/10 Excellent! (1,005 reviews)
"your unit bathrooms need an upgrade. it would be inexpensive to use a piece of furniture at the sinks. the furniture in the italian restaurant could also be better."
Reviewed on Jul 11, 2026
The Shoals Suites and Slips
61600 Main Rd Southold NY
$397 nightly
The price is $450 total per night from Jul 26 to Jul 27
$450 total
Jul 26 - Jul 27
Total with taxes and fees
This hotel features a bar/lounge, a coffee shop, and a communal living room. A business center, a picnic area, and express check-out are also on offer.
9.4/10 Exceptional! (292 reviews)
"Had an amazing stay here during the off season with our newborn. The room was clean and grounds were beautifully maintained. Can’t wait to come back here this summer to see the property in full action."
Reviewed on Jul 8, 2026
Hyatt Place Long Island East End
451 East Main Street Riverhead NY
Fully refundableReserve now, pay when you stay
$269 nightly
The price is $307 total per night from Aug 2 to Aug 3
$307 total
Aug 2 - Aug 3
Total with taxes and fees
A marina and an outdoor pool are featured at this smoke-free hotel. Traveling on business? Take advantage of the 24-hour business center and free WiFi in public ...
9.2/10 Wonderful! (1,003 reviews)
"Lovely front desk staff"
Reviewed on Jul 9, 2026
Sag Harbor Inn
45 West Water Street Sag Harbor NY
$469 nightly
The price is $536 total per night from Jul 19 to Jul 20
$536 total
Jul 19 - Jul 20
Total with taxes and fees
An outdoor pool is featured at this hotel, along with free self parking. Enjoy the free continental breakfast each morning. A fireplace in the lobby and luggage ...
9.4/10 Exceptional! (642 reviews)
"Just a couple of things, TVs need to be bigger and more modern. A free golf cart shuttle to town would be a good idea."
Reviewed on Jul 4, 2026
The Sagaponack
3720 Montauk Hwy Wainscott NY
$449 nightly
The price is $506 total per night from Jul 29 to Jul 30
$506 total
Jul 29 - Jul 30
Total with taxes and fees
A seasonal outdoor pool is featured at this bed & breakfast, along with free self parking. WiFi in public areas is free. A communal living room and luggage storage ...
8.8/10 Excellent! (275 reviews)
"Free bikes and breakfast bar were a nice bonus"
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2026
The Harbor Front Inn
209 Front St Greenport NY
$467 nightly
The price is $534 total per night from Jul 28 to Jul 29
$534 total
Jul 28 - Jul 29
Total with taxes and fees
This hotel features a 24-hour gym and a seasonal outdoor pool. Business travelers can take advantage of the free WiFi in public areas. Enjoy the free continental ...
8.8/10 Excellent! (624 reviews)
"Absolutely perfect stay at the Harbor Front. The staff are all absolute gems! One of the front desk people even waited for us with towels when we got caught in a massive sudden summer storm! Pool was also excellent, and we were able to spend time at the sister property, Soundview. All in all a wonderful ..."
Reviewed on Jul 11, 2026
Breakers Montauk
769 Old Montauk Highway Montauk NY
$351 nightly
The price is $402 total per night from Jul 29 to Jul 30
$402 total
Jul 29 - Jul 30
Total with taxes and fees
This motel features a restaurant, an outdoor pool, and a bar/lounge. Free self parking, a coffee shop, and a terrace are also offered.
8.6/10 Excellent! (209 reviews)
"Clean, efficient, updated hotel both inside and outside property. Pool looked lovely, nice size and easy access to town and beach on OMH. We were only there for a night. Room was very small and AC unit is loud. Mattress was sub par but overall room was clean and quaint. All amenities offered were ..."
Reviewed on Jul 10, 2026
North Fork Resort
690 Queen St Greenport NY
$368 nightly
The price is $420 total per night from Jul 28 to Jul 29
$420 total
Jul 28 - Jul 29
Total with taxes and fees
A seasonal outdoor pool, free self parking, and laundry facilities are featured at this cottage. WiFi in public areas is free. A picnic area and barbecue grills ...
9.4/10 Exceptional! (30 reviews)
"Overall the stay was pleasant. The cottages are well maintained. This property is still developing so there was active construction. It listed some amenities that were not yet available and some that were only available through a weekend stay which we did not have with a Sunday-Tuesday booking. I ..."
Reviewed on Jul 8, 2026
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
3 Star Hotels Shelter Island
Maybe you’ve got to travel for work, or perhaps you’re finally ready to book that much-deserved vacation—regardless, it’s time for you to get on a plane and you’re going to make the most of it. You’ve traveled enough to know how important a comfy bed and room service can be, so booking a hotel with all the amenities you need is a priority.
You can find 3 star hotels in Shelter Island that keep you close to all the great sightseeing and activities around the area, or even book a place that’s a bit more secluded, if that’s what you prefer. No matter what you’re looking for—whether you’re all about the location or are invested in on-site perks--Travelocity will help you find the accommodation that works best for you.
When it comes to options, you’ll have them. The Shelter Island 3 star hotels give you plenty of choices as far as access to the best areas, and many also offer a breakfast buffet, as well as plenty of other amenities like high-speed Wi-Fi and an on-site pool or spa.
Whatever you’re looking for on your next getaway, browse Travelocity’s big selection of hotels to ensure you get the best possible deal. Book one of the best 3 star hotels in Shelter Island today!
Recent Shelter Island hotel reviews by fellow wanderers
Pier Blue Inn Old Saybrook - Essex
5 out of 5
Posted 9 hours ago
Travelocity Verified Review
"Still the same wonderful little place as the last time I stayed here!"
A verified traveler stayed at Pier Blue Inn Old Saybrook - Essex
