Book a hotel near Martha's Vineyard Museum, Vineyard Haven

"Great location and lovely cottage! Host was very helpful!"

"Excellent place, location and the front desk assistant (Spencer) was extremely friendly and helpful. He was one of the best hosts I have ever seen. Went above and beyond. "

"People at the front desk were amazing. Very nice exceptional service."

"Mike is a wonderful host, communicates"

"Great hotel on the island with history"

"We had a fantastic stay at the Dexter for a wedding weekend. Our group unanimously declared it one of the largest and nicest homes any of us have ever rented. The kitchen is gorgeous- equipped with more than enough dishes, silverware and kitchen gadgets- often a concern in rentals. Every room was clean and coastal chic, the beds were comfy as well. It’s so rare to find a place for such a large group that still allows for privacy, space, and ample bathrooms. The “sofa” bedroom was private and included a half bath- there was so much common living space it didn’t feel like a makeshift accommodation and our friends who stayed in that room were very happy as well. The captains suite was GIGANTIC and our group had a blast getting ready for the wedding together up there. While not well advertised in the listing, the outdoor shower was a favorite feature for many. Others lamented that they wished they had more time to read cozied up on the porch and by the fire pit during down time as it was so peaceful. We honestly didn’t have a single criticism and were just wowed by every aspect of the house- tons of games, fresh flowers on the coffee table, takeout menus, Keurig cups, local tips.With a perfect location, walkable to ferry, beach, cafes and shops, a car is definitely not necessary, but it was a perk to have ample parking. Finally, Alex made all of the logistics a breeze. She was unbelievably quick to reply and generously flexible with timing. We can’t wait to come back!"