Book a hotel near Pickleville Playhouse, Garden City

"We loved our stay at this home. The kitchen was so spacious and easy for a lot of people to maneuver in. Not having to eat in shifts was such a big bonus - plenty of eating areas. The kitchen was well equipped. Everything we needed we found. The house itself was roomy and spacious. The space was well planned. Of course, the hot tub was a big hit. One of my favorite aspects (I know it's trivial,) but it was so nice not having to use industrial sandpaper-like toilet paper. It's these kinds of little things that make for a great stay. And ours was definitely a great stay. We would consider renting this place again."

"The home was spacious and clean and was perfect for our reunion. We loved the access to the beach thru the resort and how close we were to all of the activities in the area. Great stay!"

"Clean, easy to get to, good for ages of our family"

"2nd time we've stayed here with our big family and we love it. I'm noting they don't have blackout curtains on any windows because that was hard for us with little kids."

"Great house for 12 people to share. Plenty of rooms, beds, and tvs! Huge pantry, fun hot tub, tons of towels, more than the usual amount of trash bags/paper towels/laundry detergent/shampoo/etc which was great. Close to all the restaurants and shops, and being able to use the Ideal resort was great. Would stay again!"

"We had a great stay. The home was very clean and there was plenty of space for everyone. Plenty of extra blankets and really comfy bed pillows. Great communication with the host. I only gave it 4 stars because of the beds. The mattresses are all super hard and everyone woke up every day super sore. Also, there’s a security camera in the hot tub area which wasn’t disclosed in the property details. I understand the need for it but it made me a little uncomfortable knowing there was a security camera capturing footage of my teenage girls in the hot tub."