Book a hotel near Castalia Pond, Castalia

"We always love staying at castaway Bay. A few disappointments this time. It seems they opened and closed a lot of the slides. We went to get ice cream on Saturday night and they were out of almost every topping. They said they were out of sprinkles but I saw a box there on the counter. I think they just didn't want to open the new box because it was the end of the evening. There's not a lot of other options so they should cater until the end of the day. "

"Great place to stay! Thanks for everything!"

"The place was very nice and close to all the fun places in Sandusky. We enjoyed the hot tub and the host was great with communication. Theres also a bar / restaurant within walking distance from the place. We had a great time here! Thanks for having us!"

"This is a great little house centrally located to everything. Really nicely decorated and really thoughtful touches throughout! We would definitely stay again!"

"Host extremely quick to respond. The gift basket with a personal note to my family was just amazing"

"Had a great mini vacation for a few days. Gome had everything we needed and loved kayaking the canal and bay. The fall colors where breathtaking. Really enjoyed having a hot tub to watch the stars in at night. "