Book Hotels in Starr Island
Cabins, apartments, houseboats! We offer comfortable & private vacation rentals
Save an extra 10% or more on select hotels with Member Discounts
Access exclusive hotel deals, only with the Travelocity app
Check prices for these dates
Top Starr Island hotels
The Dudley Inn
"Great property and location in Bala!"
Reviewed on May 1, 2026
Lakeside 5BR Cottage in Bala – Group Getaway
"The property was the perfect place to relax and unwind with my family. We even had a very rainy day and the location was lovely to spend time in and play games to bide the time. The little town of Bala is lovely with some great places to eat.Thank you for the pleasure of staying at your ..."
Reviewed on May 26, 2026
Rawley Resort, Spa & Marina, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
"We had an exceptional one-night stay at the Rawley Resort. The location is amazingly beautiful and it's well set up for taking advantage of the scenery. The room was more than we expected and had a lovely view over the water (perfect at sunset). We had one evening meal and it was 10/10 perfect. Couldn't ..."
Reviewed on May 22, 2026
Sherwood Inn
"This is a beautiful property with a very authentic Muskoka vibe. The views and sunsets are incredible."
Reviewed on May 26, 2026
Christie's Mill Inn & Spa, BW Premier Collection
"The hotel is old and outdated the food was ok rooms had a nice view of the water"
Reviewed on May 25, 2026
The Bala Bay Inn
"The hotel was very clean"
Reviewed on May 15, 2026
Gwanatchewan Cottage - Private Island
Rocky Crest Golf Resort
Sunnylea Resort
Starr Island Hotel & Travel Guide\n
Informed travelers will learn there is only 1 room option within a convenient drive of Starr Island's heart, so try booking somewhere to sleep well before your departure date.
A fantastic option when you are looking to stay within a short walk of the center of Starr Island, is the Gwanatchewan Cottage - Private Island.
You should check out the Rocky Crest Golf Resort or the Christies Mill Inn & Spa. The Rocky Crest Golf Resort is located just 18 miles (29 kilometers) away from the heart of Starr Island. The Christies Mill Inn & Spa, is situated only 19 miles (30 kilometers) away. An alternative option is to investigate the Little Lake Inn or the Super 8 Midland.
When you have some spare time, adventurous explorers could explore the other scenic and cultural delights of the Southern Ontario region. Southern Ontario is the home of beaches. Commonly visited visitor sights include traditional villages and churches. Common pastimes in this pocket of Canada include skiing, cross-country skiing and snow shoeing.
Are you looking for things to do? Consider spending a few hours checking out Arrowhead Provincial Park and Hidden Valley Highlands, which can be found in Huntsville, 45 miles (69 kilometers) northeast of Starr Island. When you want to get to Huntsville, be sure to check out the Holiday Inn Express & Suites Huntsville and Best Western Plus Muskoka Inn. 55 miles (91 kilometers) to the southwest of Starr Island, you'll also find Owen Sound, which features the Best Western Inn On The Bay and Comfort Inn Owen Sound. The Harrison Park and Inglis Falls are other frequented places to visit in Owen Sound.
Why not spend a few hours cheering wildly with Southern Ontario's sports obsessives at a local match. Barrie Molson Centre is located 50 miles (78 kilometers) to the south of Starr Island. Travelers who enjoy the ease of finding a hotel in the neighborhood, book in the Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites Barrie or Hampton Inn & Suites Barrie.
Situated 95 miles (150 kilometers) from the heart of Starr Island is Pearson International Airport. Find accommodation nearby at Sheraton Gateway Hotel In Toronto International Airport or Residence Inn by Marriott Toronto Airport.
Frequently asked questions
Recent Starr Island hotel reviews by fellow wanderers
Sherwood Inn
"This is a beautiful property with a very authentic Muskoka vibe. The views and sunsets are incredible."
Explore More Ways to Travel with Travelocity
- Tiny Hotels
- Seguin Hotels
- B&B in Penetanguishene
- Cabins in Penetanguishene
- Cottages in Penetanguishene
- Penetanguishene Hotels
- Lodges in Penetanguishene
- Vacation Homes in Penetanguishene
- Cottages in Bala
- Guest Houses in Bala
- Bala Hotels
- Lodges in Bala
- Resorts in Bala
- Hotels near The Rock Golf Course
- Hotels near Massasauga Provincial Park
- Adults Only Resorts & in Georgian Bay
- All Inclusive Resorts & in Georgian Bay
- Hotels on the River in Georgian Bay
- Ski Resorts and in Georgian Bay
- Georgian Bay Hotels
- Houseboats in Georgian Bay
- 4 Star Hotels in Port Carling
- Cabins in Port Carling
- Cottages in Port Carling
- Pet Friendly Hotels in Port Carling
- Port Carling Hotels
- Motels in Port Carling
- 5 Star Hotels in Port Severn
- B&B in Port Severn
- Cabins in Port Severn
- Cottages in Port Severn
- Beach Resorts & in Port Severn
- Hotels with Hot Tubs in Port Severn
- Pet Friendly Hotels in Port Severn
- Port Severn Hotels
- Motels in Port Severn
- Rv Parks in Port Severn
- Villas in Port Severn
- Cabins in Honey Harbour
- Cottages in Honey Harbour
- Honey Harbour Hotels
- Vacation Homes in Honey Harbour
- Hotels near Six Mile Lake Provincial Park
- Big Chute Hotels
- Vacation Homes in Big Chute
- Hotels near Midland Golf and Country Club
- Cottages in MacTier
- Ski Resorts and in MacTier
- Mactier Hotels
- Cottages in Otter Lake
- Hotels with Hot Tubs in Otter Lake
- Otter Lake Hotels
- Motels in Otter Lake
- Cottages in Port McNicoll
- Port McNicoll Hotels
- Hotels near Hardy Lake Provincial Park
- Hotels near Georgian Bay Islands National Park
- Wyebridge Hotels
- Victoria Harbour Hotels
- Hotels near Torrance Barrens Dark-Sky Preserve
- Waubaushene Hotels
- Hotels near Awenda Provincial Park
- B&B in Midland
- Cabins in Midland
- Chalets in Midland
- Cottages in Midland
- Extended Stay Hotels in Midland
- Beach Resorts & in Midland
- Cheap Hotels in Midland
- Hotels with smoking rooms in Midland
- Midland Hotels
- Balm Beach Hotels
- 3 Star Hotels in Minett
- Cabins in Minett
- Guest Houses in Minett
- Kid Friendly Hotels in Minett
- Minett Hotels
- Perkinsfield Hotels
- B&B in Torrance
- Holiday Park Resorts in Torrance
- Beach Resorts & in Torrance
- Kid Friendly Hotels in Torrance
- Torrance Hotels
- Motels in Torrance
- Villas in Torrance
- Muskoka Lakes Hotels
- Tay Hotels
