Vacation Homes in Shelter Island, NY

Vacation homes in Shelter Island make for a different travel experience. Your holiday home will allow you to feel at home during your visit. You’ll usually have more space, more privacy, and extra amenities not typically included with hotel stays.

Private Shelter Island rental homes range between $205 - $849 per night. Prices change based on seasonal demand, travel dates, property location, capacity, amenities, etc.

To cancel your vacation home, you must reach out to the individual property manager. Their contact details are available in your itinerary. For more information, head over to our customer service portal. Use the ‘free cancellation’ or ‘reserve now, pay later’ filters to find the most flexible options for your bookings.

There are some exciting amenities available in Shelter Island vacation home rentals. You might look for Shelter Island rental houses with a private pool or free Wi-Fi. Some popular amenities also include a private hot tub, air-conditioning, laundry facilities, and a games room. 

Vacation rentals in Shelter Island offer other accommodations that may interest you. Some have resort-like amenities such as a fitness center, bar/lounge, or swimming pool.

You’ll typically get cheaper rates when staying during the off-season, . Prices are usually at their lowest for stays in . are the most popular months to visit.

Travel smart with Travelocity. Search over 1 million properties worldwide and access an incredible selection of holiday homes in Shelter Island. Our members save 10% or more on select hotels, and if you find a lower price, we’ll match it with our Price Match Guarantee. Get started finding Shelter Island hotels and vacation homes that best suit your stay. We also have deals for flights, and Shelter Island car rentals. You’ll save even more when you bundle your items into a Shelter Island vacation package!

There are 1699 rental homes in Shelter Island. Enter your travel dates to check availability.

Private vacation homes vary in price, and we’ll help you get the best deal possible. Use the map feature to compare rental house prices in different neighborhoods. Also, try adjusting your dates to compare nightly rates within a similar timeframe.