Romantic Hotels in San Juan Island, WA

"What a wonderful and magical place to stay. The home is well kept and the grounds are beautiful. It's a cozy, warm home. Great place to come back to after venturing around the Island(s) Yet, there is so much to keep you busy at the home that there really isn't much need to leave. Having the Kayaks was awesome. We kayaked in the bay multiple times during our stay. Each time on the kayaks we had multiple stellar seals hanging out with us the entire time. Not just a few, but honestly, probably about 20 of them would pop their heads up and check us out. Very curious of whom and what we were. We had 4 kayaks out and each of us had at least 2 seals tailing us, literally feet from our kayaks. One evening we were out on the water with clear skies, full moon with our seal friends hanging out. Pure magic. I'll never forget that evening, especially for our kiddos. If you enjoy shellfish, there is absolutely no shortage in the waters that surround you. Just prepare to cook it outside due to house rules which we can certainly understand. They are on a sensitive septic system which means even flushable items need to go into trash. Not a big deal for us whatsoever, but for some.. it may be. None of this mattered to us because the home , location, and grounds are priceless. Just messaging with the homeowner you can tell that she's naturally a great host. She responds literally within minute's. We can't think of anything we'd change about our experience, besides maybe a second mirror Lol "

"Great location in town "

"It was fine for a work hotel."

"The room was beautiful and the staff were excellent. "

"Nice room. Nice location."

"I was extremely disappointed with our winter break stay at Tucker House. I booked through Expedia specifically because the listing advertised many amenities (hot tub, full-service spa, library, etc.), which were the primary reason my family chose this property. None of these amenities were available to us in the suite we were given. On the day of arrival, the property was unresponsive when I asked where the amenities were, as the owner was apparently out of the country. When I finally received a response, I was told the amenities were “not available for our suite” and that this was disclosed in fine print sent after booking. This was not clearly communicated during the booking process, and had it been, we would not have stayed here. The owner offered no real resolution-no refund, no alternative accommodation, and took no accountability, instead blaming Expedia. A 15% discount on a future stay was offered, which is not a meaningful solution and will not be used. Expedia, however, was very responsive and provided a partial refund, for which I was grateful. Positives: the location is central and walkable to shops and restaurants. The unit was clean and adequately stocked. However, it is a standalone suite above a small restaurant and requires stairs, making it inaccessible for anyone with mobility challenges. A coffee maker would also have been appreciated. Overall, the lack of transparency, poor communication, and refusal to take responsibility overshadowed the positives."