Explore top 2026 4 Star Hotels in Shelter Island
Seize Your Someday with our amazing deals for the whole family!
Save an extra 10% or more on select hotels with Member Discounts
Access exclusive hotel deals, only with the Travelocity app
Check prices for these dates
Top Shelter Island 4 Star hotels
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
"-"
Reviewed on Jul 10, 2026
Montauk Yacht Club
"NO ROOM SERVICE BATHROOM WAS BROKEN"
Reviewed on Jul 10, 2026
Sound View Greenport
"The staff was helpful and nice. The exterior of the property was fine and the landscaping pretty. However the room was awful - not particularly clean, a noisy, wall ac plugged in next to the bed, felt like a renovated motel room. Sorry not worth $700/ night."
Reviewed on Jul 8, 2026
Marram
Offshore Montauk
"The standard room was a bit small, so we upgraded to a one-bedroom suite, which was fantastic! The hotel’s location is within walking distance of town, making it very convenient. I would definitely recommend it!"
Reviewed on Jul 12, 2026
The Pridwin Hotel
"We had such an amazing time at the Pridwin! The hotel is gorgeous and everything is kept clean and organized for guests!"
Reviewed on Jul 5, 2026
The Maidstone
Faraway Sag Harbor
Journey East Hampton
"Very clean and great staff"
Reviewed on Jun 27, 2026
Topping Rose House
"Amazing"
Reviewed on May 29, 2026
4 Star Hotels Shelter Island
Looking to live it up on your vacation with a bit of luxury? Or maybe you’ve decided that your boss can afford to put you up at a place of your choice on your next business trip?
Come on, you deserve it!
The best part about staying in Shelter Island 4 star hotels is that you’ll often be close to all the local sights and attractions. Whether you’re visiting the area for the first time or you’re back in town for more fun, a 4 star hotel is going to put you right in the heart of all the action.
Plus, you can rest easy knowing that you’re being well taken care of during your visit. Instead of worrying about where to eat or what to see, your friendly hotel staff will be happy to help you get whatever you need.
The best four star hotels in Shelter Island will also frequently include access to high-quality fitness centers and pools, so you’ll feel like you’re staying in an exclusive resort rather than a hotel. You won’t have any excuse for not keeping up with your workout routine!
If you’re looking for 4 star hotels in Shelter Island, you’ll find the most bang for your buck by booking your stay with Travelocity. Go explore a new city, and know you’re getting the best deal on a great hotel with the Travelocity Price Guarantee.
Recent Shelter Island hotel reviews by fellow wanderers
Offshore Montauk
"The standard room was a bit small, so we upgraded to a one-bedroom suite, which was fantastic! The hotel’s location is within walking distance of town, making it very convenient. I would definitely recommend it!"
