4/10 Poor
Caysi H.
May 18, 2026
This property is a great location if you are staying in Penn Yan and more spacious inside than the photos look online. We were excited to stay and happy upon check in.Unfortunately, our experience with this host became very uncomfortable and unprofessional. On day 3 of 4 while we were out at wineries, the host began calling and messaging us in an accusatory and alarmed manner regarding alleged property damage, despite us using the property in a normal way and cooperating fully by allowing immediate access to inspect the unit. The tone and approach felt unnecessary and created a stressful environment during our stay, despite us confirming over and over that nothing out of the norm occurred. We understand that maintenance issues can happen, but guests should not be made to feel blamed or intimidated before any investigation is complete. We would not stay here again based on how the situation was handled.
Caysi H.
Stayed 3 nights in May 2026















