My husband, college-aged son, and I spent the long weekend at the Whitetail Cottage. My husband and I spent two days skiing at Whiteface. Our son wasn't able to ski with us because he had a bad cold; fortunately he had three very comforable bedrooms to choose from in which to recover.
The house is clean, cute, comfortable, and cozy. My one suggestion is that the current (historically-appropriate) livingroom furniture be replaced with more comfortable furniture (e.g., cushy sectionals). Also, the house appears to be fairly new to the market and isn't yet stocked with a few basic things like sugar, coffee filters, aluminum foil, etc.
I would most definitely rent the Cottage again in the future and will recommend it to my friends and family!