Book a hotel near Saint Mary Star of the Sea, Old Town Key West

"I had an ocean front suite is was wonderful. The room was very clean and well presented. I ate the restaurant a few times during my stay and it was perfect everytime. I also used the fitness center and valet and everything was wonderful. "

"The place is very rundown and needs a major overhaul to bring it back to life. Upon seeing the motel from the outside, that was our first indication of how rundown it was , our room inside was just as bad, but it was clean. Both pool areas are decent. The place is very overpriced. I won’t return."

"We stayed in the Adults ONLY Duval Gardens. We enjoyed the privacy and location on Duval Street. It was nice to have the option of the amenities at the resort for the different pools and beach access. Free breakfast too! We would stay here again. The room was clean, staff is friendly no beach view at the Duval Gardens but you are right on Duval Street where all the restaurants and shopping are. No phones either, staff was accessible through text."

"Friendly staff. Close to Duval street. Amenities include bike rentals. "

"Second time we have stayed here.Staff is excellent, accommodating. The property is very well maintained and a great location."

"The house and rooms are very clean. The property is awesome, and close too everything in old key west. We are going to make the mermaid and alligator a yearly trip from now on. It is a wonderful property."