Book a hotel near Fulling Mill Brook Preserve, Chilmark

"Loved loved this house and location! Absolutely beautiful setting and fantastic home. Small and quaint and easy to manage, especially with the dogs. Clean, and extremely well-maintained. We absolutely loved it and would definitely come back again and again!"

"This whole experience was better than I could have imagined. The cottage was beautiful in a perfect setting. my Hosts went the extra distance. I didn't arrive until close to midnight. My hosts had left fruit, salad, yogurt and ice cream for me. Since I was unable to get a rental car this meant I had something to eat in the morning. I will definitely stay there again! "

"Debs place was perfect for all of our needs. Very spacious, quiet and safe but not far from anywhere you want to go on the island. I would absolutely recommend her home and would stay again!! "

"We had a wonderful stay at this house. We really enjoyed the location and beach pass to Lambert’s Cove. The host was response and friendly. The house was very cute and had plenty of space for all of us. "

"We had such a wonderful stay at this house! The layout was perfect — all the bedrooms were spacious and comfortable for our whole group. We especially loved the bright, open living space and the kitchen, which made gathering together so easy. The house was clean and full of natural light.The back deck with its patio seating was the perfect spot for an early morning coffee, and the large open field was great for a soccer game with our group. Plus, the hot tub was an amazing bonus. It was so much fun after a long day!We truly enjoyed every part of our stay and would absolutely love to come back again!"

"This house was perfect for us -- two couples and one pup -- for an off-season getaway. The location is quintessential "Up-Island" with sweeping views of Menemsha Pond, easy access to walks and hikes, nature galore, and several modest 1950's midcentury homes in the area. The kitchen was stocked with everything we needed to cook two great dinners at home, and the new Beetlebung Farm stand is super close for fresh bread, veggies, and more. We can't wait to come back! (Only caution is to take tick checks very seriously this time of year...) "