We had the most amazing stay at Caicos Cottage. The location was wonderful with just a few steps to the beach. We had a few days following a storm that the seas were rough as the tide was going out, and the pool provided a perfect retreat.
As many have described, there are very few other people on the entirety of the beach, given we were there over spring break we did see a few more, but by no means considered it busy.
The house was as pictures, with the master bedroom facing the ocean with a wonderful breeze the entire time we were there. The house overall stayed cool with all the patio doors open. We did need to run the air conditioning in the second bedroom a slight amount each night to initially cool it off.
Would highly recommend this property for a small family stay on the island. It allows you to adventure and check out North and Middle Caico easily.
A few tips for your visit: there are local grocery stores, but selection is limited, leave yourself enough time to stop and get your produce in Provo before getting on the ferry. Also consider packing dried goods in and bringing in store packaged frozen meat for additional selection from home. Purchase your ferry tickets in advance and arrive early - we did see one family get turned away because the ferry was over capacity. Finally, Al's rental car is the primary option with pickup right at the ferry terminal. Book far in advance, you may need to follow up a few times to confirm your booking.