Customized for your search:

Hotels in Shelter Island, CA

Shelter Island hotels
Shelter Island

Hotel + Flight Deals in Shelter Island

See all Shelter Island Package Deals

Shelter Island Hotels

Humphreys Half Moon Inn & Suites - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 3.5 Stars
$460

Humphreys Half Moon Inn & Suites

2303 Shelter Island Dr, San Diego - Map
 
 
"A little dated, but comfortable."
The hotel was a little dated. They're currently remodeling many of the bungalows on the waterfront and they look like they'll be really nice. Ours had a bit of a mildewy smell (we were told it was the humidity. Location is right on the waterfront.), but it was comfortable and seemed clean enough. The bed was nice, which seems more and more rare. I left out some of my essential oils and two of them disappeared. It was a small theft and at first I thought I just misplaced them, so I didn't report it, but I made sure and locked EVERYTHING up after that. Unfortunately I later had a bra disappear too...and I know where I left that! The hotel staff was polite, but not exactly warm. The restaurant was lovely and the view was stunning. Food was delicious and a great place for a special dinner. The waitresses were exceptional and friendly. The hot tub was nice, but several drunken locals sneaked in and were disruptive. They claimed to do it often to different area resorts, but liked Humphries the best for their lack of concern. We avoided the hot tub after that. Unfortunate because the pool area was really lovely and clean. In the end, the price was right and we'd probably stay again especially considering the updating and location, but we'll certainly be more cautious with our belongings.
A Traveller
Humphreys Half Moon Inn & Suites sits on 14 acres adjacent to a yacht-filled marina overlooking San Diego Bay.More
Bay Club Hotel & Marina - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 3.0 Stars

Bay Club Hotel & Marina

2131 Shelter Island Dr, San Diego - Map
 
 
"The place to stay on the bay"
I would definitely stay here again. The staff was friendly, helpful, and available. The hotel even has a vacation atmosphere. We ate several meals other than breakfast in the restaurant. The food was fresh and delicious. The area around the hotel is wonderful for walking or just sitting on a bench and watching the boats in the bay.
Traveller from Dahlonega, GA, USA
3 miles from the San Diego Airport, Bay Club Hotel & Marina is 5 miles from SeaWorld, the cruise-ship terminal, Seaport …More
Kona Kai Resort & Spa, A Noble House Resort - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 3.0 Stars

Kona Kai Resort & Spa, A Noble House Resort

1551 Shelter Island Drive, San Diego - Map
 
 
"disregard outdated or malicious reviews"
I took a risk and booked this hotel despite the disparaging reviews and am so glad that i did. The hotel and room that i had (Bay view, King room) was wonderful and flawless. Absolutely NO odors, dirtiness, the room was very obviously renovated recently, the bathrooms were all new and the room looked exactly like in the hotel's pictures. The service and staff was also first rate. I have no idea how this hotel was in the past but as of 10/21/13 it is wonderful and I have to say that the location is phenomenal and the price extremely reasonable. 
dongiovannifaust from Los Angeles, CA
Situated at the tip of Shelter Island, this 8-acre resort is 6 miles (9.7 kilometers) from SeaWorld and Seaport Village …More
Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 3.0 Stars

Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

2051 Shelter Island Dr, San Diego - Map
 
 
"Wonderful assistance from staff."
I always stay in this hotel when I have late night pick-ups or drop offs at the airport, and though there are several buildings to the hotel, each a little different, I have always had excellent rooms with pleasing views. This time, though we were in a very pricey room, I was so disappointed I wanted to leave. No view but to the parking lot; had to close the dark blinds so folks couldn't look in. This is not why I book on Shelter Island! It's so lovely here, I want to see it. I finally got the courage to call the front desk and ask if there were any other rooms. Within 15 minutes we were upstairs, looking out on the marina, with fresh breezes blowing in. Thank you so much! Although I had a crazy night going back and forth to the airport at odd hours, the view was lovely, afternoon, night, and morning. Staff was polite and very helpful, rooms spotless.
Traveller from Descanso, CA
This hotel is set on Shelter Island, surrounded by San Diego Bay and a private marina; Old Town is 5 miles away, and downtown …More

Top Hotels Near Shelter Island

La Quinta Inn & Suites San Diego Old Town/Airport - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 2.5 Stars

La Quinta Inn & Suites San Diego Old Town/Airport

2380 Moore Street, San Diego - Map
 
 
"I would stay here again!"
La Quinta in Old Town San Diego, CA, may appear old from the outside, but don't let appearance full you. The rooms are clean and crisp, plenty of towels, comfortable beds, working AC, fridge and coffee pot, extremely friendly staff. There are plenty of things to do around Old Town including shopping and dining.
Traveller from Albuquerque, NM
Located in Old Town, this hotel is within a 10-minute walk of Old Town Trolley Tours and Old Town San Diego State Park …More
Sheraton San Diego Hotel and Marina - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 4.0 Stars
$312

Sheraton San Diego Hotel and Marina

1380 Harbor Island Dr, San Diego - Map
 
 
"Nice hotel close to the beach"
around stay at the hotel was a very comfortable and relaxing experience
Traveller from Atlanta
Situated on San Diego Bay with its own marina, the Sheraton San Diego Hotel and Marina is 1 mile (1.6 km) away from San Diego …More
Holiday Inn San Diego-Bayside - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 3.0 Stars

Holiday Inn San Diego-Bayside

4875 N Harbor Dr, San Diego - Map
 
 
Pictures a bit deceiving-our room looked out into the parking lot, however location great for the touristy things we traveled to see.  Hotel was quiet, so quite restful.  Employees were all friendly and helpful.  Typical room includes bed, desk, chair and small bathroom.
Dpark from Washington
This family-friendly San Diego hotel is located on the waterfront, within 1 mi (2 km) of Rock Church and NTC Promenade. Ocean …More
Point Loma Inn & Suites - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 2.0 Stars

Point Loma Inn & Suites

2933 Fenelon St., San Diego - Map
 
 
"A Nice Place to Stay"
We wanted a quiet place to stay near the Marina so we could walk over and watch the July 4th Fireworks in the Harbor. It was Great. The rooms are newly renovated and comfortable. Having a Kitchen was Brilliant because Shelter Island area was Girdlocked until Midnite. We cooked ourselves a Great Meal and relaxed. Thanks
Traveller from Southern California
Located in Point Loma, this motel is 0.9 mi (1.5 km) from Rock Church and within 3 mi (5 km) of Ocean Beach Park and Old Town …More
Hilton San Diego Airport/Harbor Island - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 3.5 Stars
$206

Hilton San Diego Airport/Harbor Island

1960 Harbor Island Drive, San Diego - Map
 
 
"Friendly staff, great restaurant"
Was in San Diego for business but had extra time to sight-see a bit as well. Very convenient to the San Diego airport, close to downtown and to Horton Plaza. I had an early flight on Sunday morning, and fortunately for me, the shuttle service to the airport started at 4:30 a.m. Enjoyed the breakfast and lunch I had in the restaurant, where the food was excellent and the prices reasonable. Hotel staff were great about welcoming me back each time I returned to the hotel. Gift shop has good snack and beverage selection and is open until 10 pm. Located directly across the street from a nice walking path flanking the bay. At the same time, one would need a car to get to most attractions conveniently. I would return to this hotel on my next visit to San Diego.
Traveller from Omaha, NE
Hilton San Diego Airport/Harbor Island is a 5-minute drive from the airport and 15 minutes from Balboa Park, SeaWorld®, and …More
Hotel Aqua Mar - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 2.0 Stars

Hotel Aqua Mar

1510 Rosecrans Street, San Diego - Map
 
 
"Convenient location."
No hangers for clothes no drawers. Would be nice if coffee maker in room. Fine for overnight not easy for a weeks stay.
Traveller from Melbourne Fl.
Located in Point Loma, this hotel is 0.8 mi (1.3 km) from Rock Church and within 3 mi (5 km) of Ocean Beach Park and Old Town …More

Search from 4 Shelter Island Hotels


    Need help booking?

    Call 1-800-881-7420
    Visit Customer Support »
    No Travelocity Cancellation Fee

    No Travelocity Cancellation Fee

    Book, change, or cancel almost any hotel without paying a Travelocity fee.

    Shelter Island Hotel Guide

    Check out our selection of hotels in Shelter Island, CA. With over 4 to choose from, you're sure to find the perfect hotel for your trip. Travelocity is your best resource for finding cheap deals and discounted rates on hotels in Shelter Island. Whether you're on a budget or looking to splurge on a luxury 5-star hotel, Travelocity will help you get the best rate.

    Read More

    Your next great travel adventure is just within reach. And if your plans ever change, Travelocity offers free and flexible cancellations. Rest easy knowing Travelocity has no hidden fees for changing or cancelling your stay in Shelter Island.

    Enter your travel dates to Shelter Island to find the best discounts on hotels today. Now go and smell the roses.

    Hide
    CollapseExpand

    Places Near Shelter Island

    *For these packages, package savings is at least equal to the cost of the flight or hotel if booked separately. Note: For packages including flights, you will be charged by the airline for the flight, but your savings on the package will equal the cost of the flight.